On 06/04/2015 05:22 PM, Sophie wrote:
Hi Sophi, just saw this message now. :D
Some comments on the details provided on the issue, don't take them as
criticism but as a long time trainer, here is my feedback with my user
experience on background.
Your feedback is always valued. :D
Also, please before making changes to a functionality make sure that you
have the whole knowledge of what it does. I don't want to put all the
comments I have on the issue, so on this special one, Jay a menu entry
is not like a tool bar that you just remove.
Yes i'm aware of the menu entries are different than toolbar buttons,
which is why i limited my removal of entries to the Edit menu.
Also when you train people on software, the first thing you tell them is
to be curious and to visit the menus if they search for something.
Yes we do want more experienced users to visit the menus, which is why
in the HIG we have stated that the menu bar should contain all commands.
> not sure why LibreOffice should be different from others here and make
> the learning curve of the functionalities more difficult.
I didnt quite follow this.
As to rely on OOo stats that were made years ago, I'm not sure it's a
good incent, the software and habits have change a lot since.
The software hasnt changed that dramatically since the OOo stats were
collected and user behaviour doesnt change that much over time as well.
I dont exclusively rely on the stats, as i do compare LO with its
various competitors (MSO, iWork, WPS, WordPerfect, Calligra,
* 'Exchange database' doesn't it belongs to bibliography?
--> no please, do not hide this function that is used a lot doing mail merge
Would 'Exchange Database' be more suitable in the Tools menu next to
* (Insert) Hyperlink and Edit > Link use the same dialog – we could also
remove it here
--> the Edit > link dialog doesn't use the same dialog as Insert, it
allow you to remove links or update them manually, automatically for
several different objects.
I'm assuming he meant Insert > Hyperlink and Edit > Hyperlink, which do
use the same dialog. :D
* Section… - never heard about ;-) - and the envelope are something like
--> this one is very common on text formatting, should be at the top
Not very commonly used according to the stats, which likely means its
commonly used only by experienced/advanced users (aka Eve). The stats
have Insert > Image > From File as the highest used entry in the menu
and its submenus and Insert > Section as one of the lowest in the first
level. Even behind Insert > Envelope and Insert > File. (the namings
given here are according to LO 4.3)
* All together I'm a little bit lost here since naming/classification
the sections is not easy; this menu is too large
--> several are too long, need to scroll to display all the items
As HIG says we have to have all of them in the menu, we can only do so
much. As you said you had to scroll to display them, i checked my laptop
which is 1280x768 and the insert menu was the longest, but i didnt need
to scroll according to today's master. It can be reduce by 1 if i move
Insert > Chart back into Insert > Object.
* Looks like a heavy multipurpose menu (I'm looking onto the screenshots
only) – no idea what's below Text - but is there a difference between
Number Format and Lists?
--> there is absolutely no need of them in the menu, plus we don't want
users to use direct formatting but rely on styles instead
There is an absolutely good reason for them. Firstly its defined in the
HIG that all commands be available in the menus, but secondly you
previously stated "when you train people on software, the first thing
you tell them is to be curious and to visit the menus if they search for
something" and if these items are not available in the menu, how would a
user discover useful shortcuts like Ctrl+] for Increase Font Size. The
menu also has commands that weren't previously easily accessible until i
added them to the toolbar (e.g. superscript, subscript, line spacing,
increase/decrease paragraph spacing, etc).
We can want users to not use direct formatting, though we present them
with direct formatting in the toolbar and also in the context menu until
recently, but it will always be used until styles are presented to users
in such an easy manner that even a beginner would understand and be
convinced that it is the only way. We dont even provide an easy means
for users to select character styles, so if a user wants to make some
text bold, he will click the bold button in the toolbar over opening the
styles and formatting dialog, switch to character styles and select
Will try to find the time to go through more of them.
Look forward to your next round of suggestions, though i had already
gone through all of Heiko's suggestions with him last wednesday after
the design meeting. :D
To unsubscribe e-mail to: email@example.com
Posting guidelines + more: http://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Netiquette
List archive: http://listarchives.libreoffice.org/global/design/
All messages sent to this list will be publicly archived and cannot be deleted
Impressum (Legal Info)
: Unless otherwise specified, all text and images
on this website are licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License
This does not include the source code of LibreOffice, which is
licensed under the Mozilla Public License (MPLv2
"LibreOffice" and "The Document Foundation" are
registered trademarks of their corresponding registered owners or are
in actual use as trademarks in one or more countries. Their respective
logos and icons are also subject to international copyright laws. Use
thereof is explained in our trademark policy