[Libreoffice-ux-advise] [Bug 83955] TRACK CHANGES: Customizing the changes toolbar

https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=83955

--- Comment #11 from Eyal Rozenberg <eyalroz@technion.ac.il> ---
(In reply to comment #10)
> Thanks Eyal for checking it out and for the feedback.
> 1. If you select or within the text of a track change and press the
> 'comment' button, a dialog appears which allows you to enter in your comment.
Why should I be able to comment only on a tracked change? ... Hmmm. Well, I
dunno, maybe it makes some kind of sense. It's Not Like MS-Word (TM), though.

> 3. Yes the accept and reject icons are the standard zoom in and out buttons,
> as unfortunately there isnt any other available icon that comes close enough
> to be suitable.

Ah, why not? Just use a [✔] and a [✖] character from whatever font you like to
make a bitmap. It's not perfect but it will do. And if the [✔] is blue or
green, and the [✖] is red, it's even more clear. And if there's something which
looks like a document in the background, probably even better.

> 7. I picked the most suitable icon that is currently available in
> libreoffice's icon tango set.

No way to add icons to that set?

> 8. The icon is of a chain, which is to symbolize locked.

I can't figure that out by looking at it. Isn't there some kind of a lock 
icon, like one of, say, these:

http://findicons.com/search/lock

> 9. The protect button is to password protect a document to preserve the
> current state that its in, likely a common thing to do after doing track
> changes.

Really? I've never used these two in conjunction. I only use track changes to
interact with someone who might make changes his/herself, never to show a
changed document without others being able to edit it also.

> I'm happy to say that within the last few days i began working on new icons
> for all the buttons,

Just noticed that after writing everything else. They're quite nice, except for
the accept/reject dialog, which is kind of ambiguous, but I can't think of a
better alternative. Maybe if you could make the dialog there slightly bigger,
and add a red and a green dot into it somehow to represent deletions and
additions? I also think [✔] and [✖] are more apporpriate than [+] and [-].

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are on the CC list for the bug.