CG6401 Introducing Calc

Dear all,

I will start reviewing Chapter 1 of the Calc Guide.

Best regards

Leo

Hej all,

Reviewed and placed in feedback folder.

Regards

Leo

Thanks Leo.

I have accepted the changes in the Preface and Chapter 1, and both are back
in the Draft folder ready for a second reveiwer.

With regards to your comment on Chapter 1, page 15 (about changing the
direction of focus movement for the Enter key), I agree that more needed to
be said as per your comment. However I changed the wording you proposed -
please let me know if you aren't happy with what is now written.

Regards,

Steve

Regards,

Steve

Hej Steve,

I fully agree with your changes, I was not aware there was a specific paragraph about the direction of focus movement.

Many thanks
Best regards

Leo

Why is it back in the Draft folder?
After the first review it is in the Feedback folder and after the second one it remains in the Drft folder or when it is ready for publishing it goes to the Published folder.
Am I right?

Kees

Stephen Fanning schreef op 26.04.2020 12:03:

kees538@libreoffice.org schreef op 27.04.2020 07:03:

Hi Kees,

I don't know whether you are right or not.

The workflow description on the Contributor's Guide page on the wiki indicates that when review comments are placed in the Feedback folder, then "the writer (or someone else, depending on book and circumstances) revises draft, removes change tracking up to that point, uploads file to Draft folder."

As we aware, the Contributor's Guide needs updating and this may not reflect current practice.

But it's the best information I have, until somebody can give me a definitive answer!

Regards,

Steve

Hello,
I am following the steps Steve indicated for Base Guide 6.2
Pulkit Krishna

IMO, the person in charge of the book cam give a definitive answer. The way
you’re doing it, and Pulkit is doing with the Base Guide, seems more
logical to me than the way Olivier or someone started doing with the
Getting Started Guide and that seems to have happened with the Writer
Guide. If I were being more active with GS or WG, I’d say do them the way
you are, too.

Jean

Just to make a little historical contrition to this thread,. When it was
decided to make the move from ODF Authors Plone instance to the the TDF
instance of Nextcloud, I established the Nextcloud directory structure
to as closely as possible replicate what we had on the ODF Authors
website with the intention that it would have, in so far as possible,
exactly the the same workflow, as outlined in Jean's workflow diagram
here:
https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Documentation/DocumentationTeamInfo/UsingAuthorsWebsite

Obviously much of this original intention has "gone by the board", but
FWIW I strongly recommend the team endeavour to adopt Jean's original
workflow principles. Even though Jean always claimed that organising the
team was like "herding cats", that principle got the job done and gave
us the basis if the documentation we have today.

I will now say goodbye and wish you all to stay safe, stay well and take
very good care of yourselves.

Best Regards
Dave Barton