RE: [libreoffice-dev] - architecture question about interproces,extension,addIn

Hi,

I found an example of add-in and was able to build, deploy and run it.
http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/SimpleCalcAddIn  (myRNG.tar deploys RNG service)

However, the 2nd and more complete example http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/CompleteAddIn
        fails at registry time with error (CannotRegisterImplementationException): loading 
component library failed: libsrvcCalc.so
> regcomp -register -r *.rdb -c *.so
 libsrvcCalc.so
 register component 'libsrvcCalc.so' in registry 'srvcCalc.rdb' failed!
 error (CannotRegisterImplementationException): loading component library failed: libsrvcCalc.so

I found some discussion online where someone had same problem with RNG (the simple Addin) and fixed 
it.
http://www.oooforum.org/forum/viewtopic.phtml?t=79491#312692

Q1. Would someone happen to know if the example is supposed to work ?
        How do I debug the error CannotRegisterImplementationException ? My LD_LIBRARY_PATH seems 
correct because I can build RNG from the same shell.

It seems when Eric found the problem with RNG, he moved a lot of things from wiki to 
code/makefile/setupenv files.
Q2. Is it possible to make the RNG example as part of the package? I can contribute the code for 
complete-Add-in if I can get it working.
        The advantage of having it as part of build is that it doesn't break and requires little 
maintenance, while wiki can silently become outdated.
        it would benefit newbies like me to get working code as part of distribution.
        Is that the preferred way to go ? I would like to hear other opinions on this.

Thanks
Neeraj

-----Original Message-----
From: Michael Stahl [mailto:mstahl@redhat.com]
Sent: Thursday, January 03, 2013 3:44 PM
To: Rai, Neeraj [ICG-MKTS]
Cc: 'libreoffice@lists.freedesktop.org'
Subject: Re: [libreoffice-dev] - architecture question about interproces,extension,addIn

hi Neeraj,

On 03/01/13 16:54, Rai, Neeraj wrote:

> Based on above text, I looked at addIns but it doesn't seem like what I
> need.  I don't want to be restricted to a function call. I need a
> component running in scalc.
>
> _http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/Documentation/DevGuide/Spreadsheets/Spreadsheet_Add-Ins_
>
> Can someone please advise what is the "fastest code as a C++ UNO
> component " mean and where can I find more docs related to it.

C++ UNO components that are instantiated in-process currently do not go
through a bridge when interacting with the LO API (although there have
been varying opinions about changing that, since it makes maintaining
backward compatibility more difficult): for such components, calling a
LO API method (or being called from LO itself) is just a C++ virtual
function call.

the best documented way to get this performance benefit is to implement
your client code as an extension.

http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/Documentation/DevGuide/Extensions/Extensions

there may also be a way to get there with less efforts, there are some
variables to add additional service rdbs to the soffice process
(URE_MORE_SERVICES/URE_MORE_TYPES) but i don't have any experience with
them; probably there is some way to implement what you want to do as a
service and then start it from inside soffice, if all else fails via a
trivial BASIC macro :)